Berlin Prosecutor Calls Police Punches on Irish Activist 'Disproportionate'
Court proceedings against a Berlin officer continued Wednesday as video evidence emerged showing two blows to Kitty O'Brien's face during a 2025 demonstration.
By Priya Marino ·

Kitty O’Brien sat in the Tiergarten district court on Wednesday, watching the playback of the moment a Berlin police officer struck them twice in the face. The officer, identified as Nils K., faces assault charges after the state prosecutor described the blows as a reaction that was “in no way appropriate.”
The incident occurred on August 28, 2025, when two police units broke up an unregistered Palestine solidarity demonstration on a busy shopping street in central Berlin. O’Brien, an Irish campaigner who uses they/them pronouns, was part of a small group chanting slogans and carrying banners. Video footage from police cameras and smartphones shows the group being pushed down the pavement. When O’Brien removed a baseball cap after being slapped, they halted and challenged the officer verbally.
Court records indicate the first punch landed when O’Brien said, “You are acting like a f**king Nazi, are your grandparents proud of you?” A second punch followed shortly after. Enis Tiede, a fellow officer on duty, testified that he saw the first blow from the corner of his eye and described O’Brien as looking “shocked.” Tiede stated that the situation could have been resolved without violence.
O’Brien’s lawyer, Benjamin Düsberg, argued that the officer’s claim of a kick to the shins was a “defensive manoeuvre” rather than active resistance. Düsberg suggested the officer may have hit a bollard with his own shin while disentangling a keffiyeh scarf from his helmet. The court reviewed 13 video clips from various angles to assess the sequence of events.
Judge Arnd Bödeker expanded the scope of the case to include both punches, a move that goes beyond the single strike listed in the original indictment. The trial also heard medical evidence detailing O’Brien’s injuries, which include a broken nose and a radial fracture in their right arm that required surgery with a metal plate and 11 screws. O’Brien testified that their arm felt “as if it wasn’t my arm” due to the swelling and lack of sensation.
Although the court ruled that O’Brien will not pay any trial costs regardless of the outcome, the officer’s rough handling of O’Brien during the subsequent arrest remains excluded from the current charges. The next full hearing date for evidence is set for December 28.






