Cincinnati Jury Orders Power Plant Owner to Pay $1.65 Million for Tree Destruction
A federal jury found that Commercial Liability Partners breached a 1986 agreement by clearing 250 trees that served as a buffer between homes and coal ash pits.
By Chioma Brooks ·

Pierce Township residents will receive $1,654,080 to restore a forested buffer that was cleared in 2019. A federal jury in Cincinnati reached the verdict on Nov. 18 after hearing evidence that the removal of 250 mature trees breached a 1986 agreement. The award includes $1.42 million for the value of the logged timber and roughly $234,000 for removing invasive honeysuckle and planting new saplings.
The dispute began after Commercial Liability Partners (CLP) purchased the 1,443-acre Beckjord power plant site from Duke Energy in February 2018. The organization Neighbors Opposed to Pit Expansion (NOPE) filed suit in 2019. They argued that CLP violated a settlement with Cincinnati Gas & Electric that required the greenbelt to remain substantially undisturbed.
Witnesses described the 2019 logging as a sudden and severe change to the landscape. They reported that bulldozers and logging trucks cut roads into the forest and removed pine, walnut, cherry, and maple trees, some of which reached 50 feet in height. The group claimed the loss of the canopy allowed invasive honeysuckle to take over, making the undergrowth so thick that deer could not penetrate it.
The case went to trial on Nov. 9 in U.S. District Court before Judge Michael Barrett. NOPE attorney Dave Altman argued that the jury needed to enforce economic consequences for the breach of the 40-year-old agreement. He stated that the group sought $3.3 million in damages to cover the value of the trees and the cost of restoration.
CLP attorney Greg DeGulias countered that the group sought an unreasonable sum. He noted that the $3.3 million claim was more than 33 times the appraised value of the greenbelt, which stood at $97,100. DeGulias also argued that photographic evidence of the pre-logging condition was lacking.
Two arborists provided competing testimony. Mark Webber, CLP’s expert, suggested the jury award zero dollars for the large trees and approximately $25,000 for seedlings, arguing the land was already restoring itself. Jeffrey Ling, NOPE’s expert, testified that restoration would cost roughly $500,000 and that the loss of the trees represented a $2.7 million value. Ling said the logging targeted high-value canopy trees and that the heavy equipment compacted the soil.
The Beckjord plant operated from the 1950s until Duke Energy closed it in 2014. The site holds more than 5 million tons of coal ash in unlined ponds. These ponds sit in the floodplain of the Ohio River, which provides drinking water for more than 5 million people. A separate trial is scheduled to address NOPE’s claims regarding the disclosure of coal ash handling and the use of a corporate shell to limit liability.





