AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsNews from America’s biggest cities.
United Media Now · 2000 Auburn Drive, Suite 200, Beachwood, OH 44122

Small business owner sues lender over alleged merchant cash advance trap

Vahe Shahinian claims a promised line of credit turned into a costly merchant cash advance, leading to a seven-year legal battle.

By Chioma Brooks ·

Illustration for: Small business owner sues lender over alleged merchant cash advance trap
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Vahe Shahinian, a Glendale, California, entrepreneur, is currently reevaluating the emails that defined his business life. In 2019, his company, which sold concert tickets and produced events, was thriving. Shahinian had been operating for 15 years, expanding from ticketing galas to producing major tours with artists like Engelbert Humperdinck. Despite his success, he faced a funding crunch when American Express declined his fifth request for merchant financing, leaving him two weeks to secure approximately $200,000 for a tour.

In response, Shahinian turned to merchant cash advances, or MCAs. These financial products offer rapid funding but often carry high fees, ranging from 25% to 200% when calculated as an annual rate. Because MCAs are structured as purchases of future sales rather than traditional loans, they operate with minimal regulatory oversight. Lenders are not always required to be licensed, and there is no legal cap on the fees they can charge. The industry has grown rapidly, filling a void left by traditional banks that often reject or delay small business loan applications.

Shahinian received an unsolicited offer from a broker for a $750,000 line of credit at an interest rate just under 9%. The broker presented the deal as a routine test of reliability, requiring Shahinian to accept a third of the sum and make daily payments of $3,600 for 30 days. After this period, he was to gain access to the remaining funds. Shahinian, who had never missed a payment in his life, agreed to the terms without legal advice. He believed the offer was a standard loan from Wall Street-based EIN Cap.

The deal quickly unraveled. Shahinian received only $228,000 initially, with the difference withheld as an upfront fee. He made the daily payments for 30 days, then 40, and eventually 50 days, but the promised line of credit never materialized. EIN Cap later argued in court that it had only provided a merchant cash advance, not a loan, and that the brokers had made the specific promises. Much of the communication between the company and the brokers remains in sealed depositions.

Shahinian’s attorney, Shane Heskin, describes the situation as "carroting," a practice where lenders dangle the prospect of a low-interest loan to induce borrowers into signing MCA agreements. Heskin notes that first-time owners and immigrants are frequent targets. Shahinian continued making payments until his bank account hit zero, a moment that marked the beginning of a financial spiral. He eventually took out additional MCAs to cover tour costs, which evaporated within days.

The debt snowballed. Shahinian tapped his own savings, his parents' equity, and borrowed from friends and best friends. Within weeks, he owed more than $1 million to his personal network. Zorik Yeghikian, a restaurant owner who lent money to Shahinian, recalled seeing his friend "drowning" in debt. Yeghikian himself had nearly lost his business to MCA payments, a experience that left him sleeping at his restaurant and working double shifts.

Shahinian decided to fight the lenders rather than fold. He sued EIN Cap and the brokers in 2019, settling with the brokers three years later to focus on the primary lender. The lawsuit accuses EIN of fraud. A private investigator was required to locate the funders for service of process. During this time, Shahinian discovered that his broker, who had used the name Bryan Stein, was actually Boris Shteyngart, a man who had previously pleaded guilty to grand larceny.

The legal battle has been protracted and costly. Shahinian tracked down hundreds of other business owners sued by EIN for debt collection, finding that many were emotional about the prospect of someone standing up to the lender. EIN has faced lawsuits in at least nine states, with most cases settled or dismissed. In one notable Illinois case, a judge ordered EIN to return profits from a deal that had prolonged a Ponzi-like scheme.

The stress of the litigation and debt took a toll on Shahinian’s personal life. After 16 years in a suburban home in Glendale, he lost his house to foreclosure. He moved in with his elderly parents, selling off his belongings and packing his cats. Every dollar from the foreclosure sale went toward mortgage debt and repaying a close friend. Although California and other states have begun requiring MCA companies to provide clearer written fee disclosures, Shahinian continues his fight, viewing bankruptcy as an admission of defeat.

Shahinian remains in his childhood bedroom, a space he never expected to occupy in middle age. He maintains that his only fault was trusting a promise he believed to be solid. The case highlights the risks small business owners face in an unregulated funding market, where the line between a helpful loan and a predatory advance can be dangerously thin.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.