Meta to pay $25 billion in New Mexico data penalty
The judge capped the fine at 1.5% of the company's current market value, despite state attorneys seeking up to $45 billion.
By Priya Marino ·

Judge Francis Mathew ordered Meta to pay $25 billion this week for violating New Mexico's consumer protection laws. The ruling marks the largest financial penalty in the company's history. It stems from a 2021 lawsuit alleging that Meta misled users about data handling practices linked to the Cambridge Analytica scandal.
The state attorney general originally requested a penalty between $35 billion and $45 billion. The theoretical maximum was $219 billion, calculated at $5,000 for each of 43 million violations. Judge Mathew reduced that figure to $25 billion. For context, Meta is currently valued at approximately $1.7 trillion. The company's stock dropped on Thursday, though analysts attributed the decline to a combination of earnings results, heavy artificial intelligence spending, and a general slide in technology stocks.
C.J. Mahoney, Meta's chief legal officer, stated that the ruling makes it "all but impossible to do business in the state of New Mexico." He characterized the lawsuit as an attempt to "impose a tax on speech" and said the company is "confident we will prevail on appeal." Meta has indicated it will fight the outcome.
This verdict adds to a series of legal losses for the company in 2026. A New Mexico jury previously ordered Meta to pay $375 million for child safety violations, with a second phase of that trial resulting in an additional $567 million order. In Los Angeles, a court ruled Meta and YouTube liable for harming a young woman's mental health through addictive design, awarding her $6 million. In August, Meta agreed to pay between $17 billion and $18 billion over ten years to settle a federal case brought by most US states over features alleged to harm children.
Corban Rhodes, a partner at DiCello Levitt, the firm representing New Mexico, noted that each trial puts evidence on the public record. The New Mexico trial released more than 100 exhibits that had been kept secret for over a decade. One document is a 2018 email from then-COO Sheryl Sandberg. Sent days after the Cambridge Analytica scandal broke, she warned that "there were a MILLION developers with access to the data" and predicted "many, many, many more moments like this in the next month and year."
Legal experts suggest that financial penalties alone may not force structural changes. Brian Quinn, a Boston College law professor, said pressure could increase if shareholders target individual directors rather than the company as a whole. Quinn noted that if the same executives keep appearing in the same set of facts, shareholders might demand the company stop indemnifying them, leaving executives less protected. Insurers may also exert influence, as a Delaware judge ruled in March that they have no duty to defend Meta against thousands of lawsuits.
Rhodes expects the next wave of litigation to center on artificial intelligence rather than earlier social media eras. The company faces continued scrutiny, but experts do not expect it to collapse from penalties alone.
More Business · Tech news · Consumer Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?






