Chinatown murder suspect had five open cases as mayor pushes Rikers closure plan
A homeless man charged with killing a woman in Manhattan had multiple pending dockets just as Mayor Mamdani announced a plan to reduce the city's jail population.
By Chioma Brooks ·

A 25 year old homeless man from New York City has been charged with the fatal beating of a 62 year old woman and the assault of a man in Manhattan's Chinatown. At the time of the arrest, Alexander Florentino was free despite having five open criminal cases against him. This situation arises at a critical moment for city policy, as Mayor Zohran Mamdani has just unveiled a comprehensive plan to close the Rikers Island jail complex.
NYPD officers took Florentino into custody at 11:30 a.m. on Saturday within the 5th Precinct. He faces charges including murder, attempted murder, two counts of strangulation, burglary, assault, and attempted assault. Court records from the New York State Unified Court System indicate that Florentino was scheduled for court appearances on December 14 across five pending dockets in Manhattan Criminal Court. These records confirm that he had been released from custody prior to the fatal attack on Friday.
The defendant's recent arrest history reveals a pattern of repeat encounters with the law. Police most recently arrested Florentino on November 18 regarding an incident that occurred two days earlier. Additionally, officers from the NYPD Transit Bureau detained him twice on November 11 in separate cases related to incidents on that same day and on August 3. He also had two open arrests dating back to September 2 and September 28.
The timing of these repeat arrests coincides with the mayor's announcement of a six year strategy to shutter Rikers Island by the year 2032. The plan aims to reduce the jail population from approximately 6,700 inmates to 4,100 by expanding alternatives to detention. Mayor Mamdani expressed his views on the matter on Friday, noting that too many New Yorkers view the criminal legal system as a revolving door.
In his statement, the mayor argued that the system cycles people in and out of jail because insufficient energy is expended to help them rebuild their lives. He emphasized that the city has both a legal and a moral obligation to close Rikers Island. The proposed reduction in population highlights the administration's focus on shifting resources toward rehabilitation and community based solutions.
Police responded to a call at 27 Catherine Street around 3:22 p.m. on Friday. Upon arrival, officers discovered a 62 year old woman who was unconscious and unresponsive. She sustained significant trauma to her face and neck. Emergency medical workers transported her to NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue, where she was later pronounced dead.
During the same incident, officers located a 66 year old man who had sustained a laceration on the right side of his face. Police reported that he had been struck over the head with a glass bottle. The man was taken to Bellevue Hospital in stable condition for treatment.
Authorities have not yet released the identity of the deceased woman, pending notification of her family. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner is currently working to determine the specific cause of death. Police have not disclosed a possible motive for the attack or confirmed whether Florentino knew the victims prior to the incident.
The Manhattan District Attorney's Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding the case or the defendant's history of open dockets. The case highlights ongoing debates in New York about balancing public safety with the goal of reducing mass incarceration.
As the city moves forward with its plan to restructure its jail system, the recent events in Chinatown have drawn attention to the status of defendants with multiple pending cases. The juxtaposition of the mayor's announcement and the defendant's arrest history has fueled discussion about the effectiveness of current detention practices.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






