AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsNews from America’s biggest cities.
United Media Now · 2000 Auburn Drive, Suite 200, Beachwood, OH 44122

Regrading the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade: Why the Heat and Bucks both look worse now

With Giannis Antetokounmpo set to face Milwaukee for the first time as an opponent on Wednesday, early returns suggest both Miami and Milwaukee came out of the blockbuster worse than initially graded.

By Priya Marino ·

Illustration for: Regrading the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade: Why the Heat and Bucks both look worse now
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Giannis Antetokounmpo will face the Milwaukee Bucks for the first time as an opponent on Wednesday, a matchup that feels as though it has been a half decade or more in the making. Miami was linked to Antetokounmpo, who spent his first 13 NBA seasons in Milwaukee, as far back as the buildup to his possible 2021 free agency. The Bucks averted that departure by trading for Jrue Holiday and ultimately winning a championship.

Milwaukee kept pushing the problem down the road, securing another extension in 2023 by trading for Damian Lillard and looking the other way when Lillard tore his Achilles in 2025, bypassing the chance to move Antetokounmpo with multiple years left on his contract when his value was highest. In the end, Heat president Pat Riley did what he has done so many times before: he got his man. With roughly four weeks of evidence since one of the bigger blockbusters in recent NBA history, and the first head-to-head meeting at hand, the regrades are in, and neither side looks good.

The Heat drop from a B+ to a C+. The obvious positive is that Antetokounmpo, despite age and injury concerns, is still mostly himself, playing at or near his Milwaukee peak and at minimum a top-10 player this season, with a case for the top five. Miami paid an All-NBA price and got an All-NBA player. There are mild signs of slippage in his age-32 season: his free-throw rate is at its lowest since 2018, though still near the top of the league, and he is scoring 1.38 points per possession at the rim, an 82nd percentile mark per Synergy Sports, after sitting in the 95th percentile last season.

He has supplemented his rim finishing with major mid-range improvement, jumping from below 39 percent over the past five seasons combined to above 51 percent this season, a crucial development given that the 3-point shot is never coming. Last year's calf injuries have not recurred. Defensively, though, the decline is hard to deny. He contested around nine shots per game when he won Defensive Player of the Year in 2020, and he is down to around six now. Opponents are shooting 6 percent worse within six feet of the basket against him, per NBA.com tracking data, a figure that was 20.4 percent in 2020.

The larger question is whether the team justifies the cost. Heat fans point to an 8-2 stretch following an 0-4 start, but most of those wins came against the bottom of the league or shorthanded opponents: the Kings, the Jazz, an overtime escape against the Clippers, the Pacers without Tyrese Haliburton, the Pistons without Jalen Duren, the Cavaliers without Evan Mobley and the Rockets without Amen Thompson on the second night of a back-to-back. Against the only two full-strength heavyweights they faced, the Lakers and Timberwolves, Miami stood no chance.

The theory of this roster depends on a top-five defense, because the offense leans heavily on shot creation from its bigs, Antetokounmpo and Bam Adebayo. Even during the 8-2 run, Miami is allowing 48.4 points in the paint per game, a well-below-average figure. The Heat must play defensively deficient players such as Klay Thompson, and possibly Tim Hardaway Jr., to survive offensively, while Andrew Wiggins has been a mess. Davion Mitchell's playmaking has been a godsend, and Miami tried and failed to get Milwaukee to take him instead of Kasparas Jakučionis in the trade. The paths to improve are narrow: the Heat are pressed against a first-apron hard cap and would need Charlotte's cooperation to amend protections on their 2027 pick just to trade a single first-rounder. They let Norman Powell walk, front-loaded Wiggins' extension and signed Hardaway to a one-year deal, a patient approach that fits oddly with a star who turns 32 in less than a month.

The Bucks fall from a C- to a D-. They dug their own hole by refusing to trade Antetokounmpo when the whole world knew they should have, starting the moment Lillard tore his Achilles in 2025, when Antetokounmpo had two years left on his deal and asset-rich teams like the Spurs and Rockets might have been interested. Instead, Milwaukee waived and stretched Lillard to sign Myles Turner. By the time the Bucks accepted reality, Antetokounmpo, on an expiring contract, controlled everything. According to ESPN, at least four teams with strong offers were turned away because he would not commit to extending with them; he wanted only the Heat or the Celtics. To their credit, the Bucks used Boston as a scare tactic to extract nearly all of Miami's available draft capital, plus Jakučionis instead of Mitchell.

Winning the negotiation has not meant winning the trade. The swing piece, Kel'El Ware, a high-risk, high-reward young big, has delivered his worst version, playing less in his third season than he did in two years with the Heat while missing shots and defending poorly. It is too early to judge Nate Ament, the No. 13 overall pick. Tyler Herro and Jaime Jaquez Jr. have been about what was expected, but both will need to be paid next summer, and Herro's arrival pushed last year's breakout guard, Ryan Rollins, to the bench. The 2031 and 2033 picks from Miami are the crown jewels of the deal, yet they are theoretically vulnerable after the NBA set a precedent in the Kawhi Leonard case that it is willing to strip draft picks acquired through trade if cap circumvention is found. The investigation is ongoing.

There is also the strange case of Trent, who played less than 40 total minutes before bizarrely leading the Bucks in playing time off the bench in Sunday's loss to the Hawks, raising the question of whether Milwaukee could have used its leverage to send him to Miami in a sign-and-trade. The Bucks are 1-13 entering Wednesday's game. That record was roughly expected once an MVP candidate was removed from a bad team, but to move the greatest player in franchise history, one of the 25 or so best the league has ever seen, and come away without a single blue-chip player or draft pick is frankly embarrassing. Milwaukee bungled this saga for a year, and even a decent ending could not undo an organization-wide debacle.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.