AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsNews from America’s biggest cities.
United Media Now · 2000 Auburn Drive, Suite 200, Beachwood, OH 44122

Fresh Senate Democrats face early test in leadership contest

Incoming senators who campaigned on change are divided over whether to support incumbent Chuck Schumer or challenger Chris Van Hollen for majority leader.

By Priya Marino ·

Illustration for: Fresh Senate Democrats face early test in leadership contest
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The Democratic Party’s incoming senators are facing an early challenge to their campaign promises as they navigate the selection of their new party leader. Although these lawmakers have not yet been sworn into office, the decision of who will guide the new majority is already testing the commitment to shake up Washington that many of them articulated during their races.

The cohort includes 13 new Democrats, representing the largest incoming Senate class in decades. Several of these officials won seats in traditionally Republican areas by pledging to act as independent voices and disrupt the status quo. They are now engaged in a familiar internal dispute, forced to choose between the longtime leader, Chuck Schumer of New York, and his challenger, Chris Van Hollen of Maryland.

Progressive newcomers, such as Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota, have thrown their support behind Van Hollen. He is campaigning on a platform that promises a more aggressive legislative strategy. In contrast, Sherrod Brown of Ohio, who is returning to the Senate after losing his seat in 2024, has expressed his support for Schumer.

Many of the incoming senators from states like Texas, Mississippi, Iowa, and South Carolina, whose victories were crucial in securing the majority, have largely remained noncommittal. Annie Andrews of South Carolina stated she is speaking with both candidates, while Scott Colom of Mississippi described himself as being in listening mode. Adam Hamilton of Kansas said on Thursday that he would not back Schumer but did not endorse a specific alternative. He told MSNow that he is seeking a leader who can unite people, noting that many in Kansas do not feel that connection with Schumer.

Schumer’s deep relationships and experience with Senate procedures give him a significant advantage ahead of the secret ballot vote scheduled for December 1. However, the hesitation of new members has placed unusual attention on first-term lawmakers. Mazie Hirono of Hawaii emphasized the need to embrace these new voices, stating that the party must ensure their talents are heard.

Andrews, a pediatrician who became the first Democrat in nearly three decades to win a Senate seat in South Carolina, called for generational change. While she initially said she would not support Schumer, she has also rejected some of Van Hollen’s policies, such as Medicare for All. She told reporters on Tuesday that she has made no final decision, asserting that the incoming freshman class itself represents the generational shift the party needs.

James Talarico of Texas advocated for new blood in the party but has not ruled out Schumer, saying he would ask tough questions to both candidates. Josh Turek of Iowa said his choice would depend on which candidate aligns best with his populist agenda. Mary Peltola of Alaska, whose election was officially called on Wednesday, told the Associated Press that she had not yet considered the leadership race.

Schumer’s allies highlight his recent success in recruiting candidates and directing campaign spending, with Ruben Gallego of Arizona comparing Schumer to a manager who leads a team to the World Series. Conversely, progressive groups like MoveOn and Indivisible have endorsed Van Hollen, arguing that Democrats need bold leadership to address affordability and accountability. Activists have even chanted for Schumer to step down at recent events.

The contest has also drawn in more established Democrats with ambitions for higher office. Jon Ossoff of Georgia, a potential 2028 presidential contender, said he has not committed to a candidate. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, who is also considering a presidential bid, announced on Thursday that she supports Van Hollen. She noted that while she is critical of some of his progressive policies, her previous stance against Schumer made Van Hollen the logical choice.

The leadership election is traditionally a private matter decided by secret ballot, but the current fight highlights the tension between maintaining caucus unity and responding to activist demands. Schumer has not indicated whether his term ending in 2028 will be his last, while Van Hollen continues to promise a more confrontational approach to the White House and changes to party operations.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.