AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsNews from America’s biggest cities.
United Media Now · 2000 Auburn Drive, Suite 200, Beachwood, OH 44122

South China Sea Code of Conduct Remains Elusive for ASEAN Leaders

Experts doubt that ASEAN and China will finalize a substantive South China Sea Code of Conduct soon, citing complex disagreements and Beijing's reluctance to accept restraints.

By Priya Marino ·

Illustration for: South China Sea Code of Conduct Remains Elusive for ASEAN Leaders
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Asia's political leaders continue to grapple with the South China Sea, a body of water that remains one of the most contested regions in the world. Despite widespread optimism from Association of Southeast Asian Nations members that negotiations for a Code of Conduct might finally conclude after more than two decades, experts indicate that a substantive agreement is not yet feasible.

The recent ASEAN summit held in the Philippines failed to produce a resolution, even though Manila had expressed its intention to finalize the Code within the current year. The fundamental disagreement centers on China's claim to virtually the entire sea. This position stands in contrast to international rulings and historical claims asserted by multiple other nations in the region.

In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled that China's so-called nine-dash line claim was invalid. However, Beijing has consistently refused to recognize that ruling. Over the past several decades, China has constructed structures on shoals to strengthen its territorial assertions and has grown increasingly aggressive in policing the area against nations like the Philippines, which maintain traditional rights to the maritime zones.

The proposed Code of Conduct is designed to address areas of dispute and competing claims between China and various ASEAN nations. Manila reported that 80% of the negotiating text had been completed, with discussions set to continue under the next ASEAN chair, Singapore. Nevertheless, analysts remain skeptical that a truly effective agreement can be reached in the short term.

Ray Powell, executive director of the SeaLight Foundation, described the annual process as a ritual where the chair commits to completion but ultimately reports that progress was not sufficient. He characterized the 80% completion figure as a meaningless statistic given the complexity and contentious nature of the issues at hand.

In contrast, ASEAN Secretary General Kao Kim Hourn expressed a more positive outlook, stating that the situation is not a failure and that both sides maintain a strong commitment to moving forward. He emphasized that there is significant leadership on both sides to get the process done.

Collin Koh, a senior fellow at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies in Singapore, noted that the remaining 20% of the text contains the most persistent problems. These issues include the geographical scope, competing interests among ASEAN member states, and enforcement mechanisms. Koh highlighted that the original aim for ASEAN to negotiate with China one-to-one has never been realized, resulting in a dynamic of multiple nations against one.

The disputes in the South China Sea have roots stretching back to the 1970s, involving claims from countries such as Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam. The region is critical due to its rich natural resources and fishing areas. Singapore has positioned itself as a neutral broker in these dialogues, aiming to preserve peace and stability by dealing fairly with all parties.

Lynn Kuok, a chair of Southeast Asia studies at the Brookings Institution, argued that while Singapore may broker compromises, the disagreements that have stalled the code for nearly a quarter century will persist. She noted that Beijing has little incentive to accept meaningful restraints while it continues to consolidate its position. Joshua Kurlantzick of the Council on Foreign Relations echoed this view, suggesting that a code of conduct is unlikely to happen soon, if ever, because China does not truly desire it.

Kurlantzick pointed to Beijing's assertive actions, such as the use of coast guard vessels against Filipino ships near the Spratly islands and Scarborough Shoal. He also noted that several ASEAN countries close to China are willing to hold up any agreement, a trend coinciding with a less clear U.S. commitment to regional defense. Powell warned that a rushed or flawed Code would be worse than none, as a weak agreement could allow Beijing to undermine the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get United Media Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.