Podcast hosts rethink score for Apple's new two-screen phone
The Vergecast hosts argue the iPhone Duo fits the tablet category better, questioning their initial 7 out of 10 rating.
By Abigail Brooks ·

The Vergecast hosts David and Nilay Patel are questioning the 7 out of 10 score they previously gave to Apple's iPhone Duo. In a new episode, they argue the device should have launched under the iPad name rather than the iPhone brand. They contend that classifying it as a tablet would better reflect its design and utility for consumers.
The debate centers on whether the phone's outer display serves a useful purpose. Hosts reference a suggestion from Daring Fireball writer John Gruber, who called the outer screen the worst iPhone ever made. The hosts discuss if the product would be viewed more favorably if it were simply marketed as the iPad Duo. They acknowledge that while the device will likely improve with software updates, it may not replace the standard phone for all users.
The episode aired on October 23, 2026. It follows the recent release of the iPhone Duo, a dual-screen device that challenged traditional smartphone definitions. The hosts aim to work through how this new form factor might change over time. They also address if the initial rating remains accurate or if the tablet argument changes the verdict.
Beyond the device review, the podcast covers a major cybersecurity flaw in PHP that affected websites this week. The hosts discuss the impact of the flaw on web security and the future of online shopping. They note that increasing use of AI agents in retail is forcing companies to adjust how they interact with customers.
The show also includes a segment criticizing FCC chair Brendan Carr. Hosts discuss an upcoming reboot at Netflix and recent confusing news regarding Google's Gemini AI model. They mention other topics from the week, including the Tesla Roadster and chaos in the AI math community.
Listeners can reach the show by calling the hotline at 866-VERGE11 or emailing vergecast@theverge.com. The hosts encourage subscriptions to stay updated on future discussions.






