Volunteer Fire Lieutenant Released After Paying $180 in Ohio Undercover Operation

John Steele, a lieutenant with the Imperial Volunteer Fire Department in Allegheny County, has been released on bond following his arrest last month. He faces allegations of agreeing to pay for sex in an undercover operation conducted by the Mahoning Valley Human Trafficking Task Force.

Court documents show Steele met with an undercover officer at the East Palestine Police Department in Ohio. Investigators say he brought $180 in cash and his cellphone to the meeting. He is currently on leave from his position with the fire department.

Community members in Imperial expressed shock over the incident. Matthew Edwards, who works at Kovach's Auto Service, called the situation vulgar and disgusting. Edwards said it was hard to accept because the lieutenant represents the community.

Thomas Swoager noted that residents are surprised by the news in a small town. He said he would not hold the fire department itself accountable for one man's actions. Swoager added that he respects the work the department does to keep residents safe during crises.

Steele's attorney requested evidence from the case, including police reports and messages between Steele and law enforcement. The lawyer said in a statement that Steele is stepping back from his role with the department.

The Mahoning Valley Human Trafficking Task Force led the investigation. Benjamin Kovach, a local resident, said the arrest was not surprising in 2026. He added that people never truly know who others are in a small community.

The Imperial Volunteer Fire Department has not responded to requests for comment regarding Steele's leave or the ongoing legal proceedings.