Cleveland Council demands fire department fix hiring gaps
Council members called the department's progress since 2013 insufficient after finding that 75% of recent hires were white men.
By Chioma Brooks ·

Cleveland City Council members on November 10 questioned the city's Division of Fire regarding a persistent lack of diversity in its workforce. The hearing, held by the Workforce, Education, Training and Youth Development Committee, centered on data showing that approximately 75% of new hires between 2015 and 2024 were white men. This statistic stands in contrast to the city's broader demographics and the goals of a federal consent decree that governed the department from 1977 to 2013.
Committee Chair Richard Starr presented findings indicating that of the city's 736 uniformed firefighters, only 99 are Black and 18 are women. Starr noted that Cleveland Police has made more progress in this area. He expressed concern that the fire department's demographic makeup does not reflect the residents it serves, particularly given that the majority of Cleveland residents are not white.
Leeanne Guzman, project director for the Civil Service Commission, outlined current hiring procedures. She explained that the city reduced the number of residency verification documents required for applicants to receive priority status. The National Testing Network has also approved City Hall as a testing center for the Civil Service Exam, a step intended to attract more local candidates. In the 2023 hiring cycle, the division received over 1,000 applications, with 25% of applicants identifying as Black or African American. More than 500 candidates passed the exam.
The hiring process relies heavily on an internal Applicant Review Committee of 17 firefighters. This group reviews the top 72 scoring files and makes recommendations to the division chief and the director of Public Safety. The 2023 cycle resulted in 35 hires from a class of 40 candidates. Committee members Stephanie Howse-Jones and Starr expressed concern that this internal process lacks independent oversight from Human Resources or other city entities.
Recruiters Antoine Cruz and Lieutenant Jeremy Caldwell discussed challenges in maintaining contact with a large applicant pool. Cruz noted that the volume of applicants makes it difficult to provide individualized support for exam preparation. He emphasized the importance of engaging with Cleveland Metropolitan School District to increase recruitment.
Howse-Jones criticized the department's current state, calling it "woefully inadequate." She pointed to the Toledo Fire Department as a model for integration and suggested Cleveland adopt similar interview practices. She urged the division to seek external support for the Review Committee. The committee will review the department's response before it presents its budget request in early 2027.
Acting Chief Vince DiTeodoro, who has served in the role since August 2026, stated that applicants currently speak with an applicant processing team but do not undergo formal in-person interviews. Director of Public Safety Dornat "Wayne" Drummond confirmed that Mayor Justin Bibb has selected a permanent chief, though the name has not been announced. The candidate has not yet been notified of the appointment.






